Saturday, May 14, 2005
This Day:

This has been happening all over the world. Be it the Three Gorges Dam on the Yangtze river in China, Sardar Sarovar Dam on the Narmada river in India, or the Sivand Dam across Bolaghi gorge in Iran, such giant projects often have the effect of destroying/submerging historical sites of immeasurable value:(. Archaeologists often have to rush to save whatever little they can, before water washes away priceless artifacts (See one of my old posts on Iran's Sivand dam here). A similar situation has arisen in South Eastern Turkey, where a massive dam on the Tigris River threatens to submerge Hasankeyf, a site of great historic importance.

Piers of a 12th Century Bridge at Hasankeyf (Courtesy: RiverNet)
An international campaign halted the project in 2002. But the project has been restarted, and it is part of the Greater Anatolia Project, a series of hydroelectric plants and dams, and is all the more controversial because of its location in the predominantly Kurdish south-east of Turkey.
Hasankeyf was an important crossroads between East and West, occupied by nine major civilisations from the Assyrians to the Ottomans. If the dam goes ahead the whole town will be submerged with the exception of the citadel, perched on top of the cliffs. Among the losses will be the Sultan Suleiman Mosque, the minaret of which is one of the most outstanding examples of early 15th-century Ayyubid architecture; the cylindrical tomb of Zeynel Bey, a rare example of Central Asian style architecture in Anatolia; and the tomb of the holy Imam Abdullah, grandson of Cafer-i Tayyar, uncle of the prophet Mohammed, a shrine visited by about 30,000 Shia pilgrims each year.
True, that human progress must go on. But there is often a lack of concern for historical ruins, as developing nations are going on the fast track to develop dams, and blow up mountains, all in the name of progress. As with the developed countries in the 18th and 19th centuries, this can only lead to a further loss to our common heritage:(:(.

(Hide) (Show)

19 Comments:

At May 16, 2005 3:24 AM, Blogger Sray said...
I know :(. But what can international sites do? Turkey is a sovereign country, and in the end, if a country does not want to protect its heritage, there is not much anyone from outside can/could do...
 
At May 16, 2005 4:29 AM, Blogger LEMNA said...
Hemm,you know,politicians come and go,many different kinds of people with variable ides come and go,somebody may like the ancient structures,else will like the modern ones,we can't stop it,but i think it is a country's heritage that gives it essense and identity,we all are responsible for it,but no way to cut the changes,we can do only our share...we can have NGO's for protecting them in our country...
 
At May 16, 2005 4:42 AM, Blogger LEMNA said...
Why are you annoyed my dear pal???
 
At May 16, 2005 8:08 AM, Blogger Unknown said...
There should be some international law against such things. And I wonder how they ever got over relegious fanatics who would oppose the submerging of the piligrim sites!
 
At May 16, 2005 8:14 AM, Blogger Sray said...
Lemna: You are exactly right. If we lose our heritage, then there is we have cut out our identity, history, our sense of ourselves. I agree that progress is necessary, but... surely a better plan can be devised that can be best of both worlds?

Sudhir: Laws dont help. What do you propose if a country breaks this law?! Put sanctions against it?! This is a question of awareness. If a country doesnt/cant protect its own heritage, no one else will.
 
At May 16, 2005 11:28 AM, Blogger Akruti said...
SRay,i need a help if u dont mind,how do i get the smileys in my blogpsots as u do? i am no good at HTML coding,can u tell me how i can do it? plz,if u dont mind:) thanks
 
At May 16, 2005 12:57 PM, Blogger Unknown said...
Whats wrong in putting sanctions against such countries?
 
At May 16, 2005 2:35 PM, Blogger Jim V. said...
Just a quick question. Where does one draw the line between preserving heritage and providing for the needs of the citizens?
 
At May 16, 2005 2:48 PM, Blogger Sray said...
Neelima: I use a lot of javascript to do that, and that would requrire a number of changes in your template. Let me if you want to do that. Else, you can do one easy thing, something like this.

1) Whenever you want to put a smiley, check this Yahoo Emoticon page.
2) Say you want to add a smile icon. Just add that image to your post, by putting a link!

If you want to do a javascript version, I can give you my code, and some directions. But you have to make some changes in your template!
 
At May 16, 2005 2:51 PM, Blogger Sray said...
Sudhir: Sanctions often create problems only for the common man, and not for the lawmakers. And they often have an adverse result: people dig in their heels when berated by foreigners, and no good is done.

Gindy: Yaa. It happened a lot in Europe and USA too. Progress comes with a lot of price :(.

Jim: Welcome to my page :). I guess there is no concrete line. But both sides have to discuss the issues in good faith.
 
At May 16, 2005 3:30 PM, Blogger Akruti said...
SRay,i am not good at all with javascript,i am a finance lecturer:( but i would love to use emoticons.i am not sure if i understood but i am going ot try with a test post.if not then i would bother u again.Hope u dont mind.Thanks a ton
 
At May 16, 2005 7:18 PM, Blogger Sray said...
Neelima, I have mailed you about this. Hope that helps... and if not, please ask me again! I dont mind it at all :).
 
At May 16, 2005 10:39 PM, Blogger Unknown said...
Agrred with sray! Sanctions dont affect the policy makers. It only makes the innocent suffer.

Arent they even bothered about losing tourists?
 
At May 16, 2005 11:12 PM, Blogger Sray said...
The hydroelectric benefits this will bring will be more than any tourism revenue, I am sure. But.... ah well!
 
At May 17, 2005 12:20 AM, Blogger LEMNA said...
Normal?!BE happpppy if not i will kill u!got it?!
 
At May 17, 2005 12:39 AM, Blogger Sray said...
Ok ok, how is my current mood? Will it do?! ;);)
 
At May 17, 2005 1:02 AM, Blogger LEMNA said...
:))*U*U:D
 
At May 17, 2005 1:10 AM, Blogger Sray said...
:))... you too :D:D.
 
At May 18, 2005 7:17 AM, Blogger Sray said...
Yaa.. this has happened and is happening the world over. And with the rate of progress, it might only increase! It is time for the world to get together and solve this mess, but.... :(:(.
 

Post a Comment