Sunday, May 08, 2005
This Day:

Amygdala is a almond-shaped structure in the human (and animal) brain, whose primary function is to regulate emotions. For example, the amygdala becomes active when we are experiencing pleasure, fear, hate, and so on. In humans, it is also the seat of biases (racial, cultural), as the amygdala conditions our brain to distrust anything that is out of the ordinary. This conditioning made sense in ancient days, when humans used to live in small tribal communities with homogenous cultural and racial structures. Now scientists from UCLA have found that negative feelings about black people may be subconsciously learned by both white and black Americans! The research is among the first to test the brain physiology of racial biases in both black and white subjects.

Amygdala (Courtesy: University of Virginia)
It seems that both whites and blacks demonstrate an increased activity in their amygdala, when presented with images of black faces. Our amygdala also fires up when we see unknown faces, so both whites and blacks were first shown the pictures in another context. So next time when they see the pictures, they should recognize them, but this did not stop the amygdala from firing up when confronted with black faces! This suggests that both whites and blacks feel threatened (typical amygdala behavior) by black faces. According to the researchers, this suggests pervasive cultural cues, to associate black people with fear.
However, the study is not conclusive. A lot of other factors (past experiences, social and cultural differences, etc.) do color the responses. More study needs to be done with larger populations, and with perhaps isolated populations of Africans in Africa to set up a benchmark against which such comparisons can be made. Another interesting avenue would be to test if the response is towards the color of the skin only; for example, by using say black and white cats (instead of humans) to test the corresponding amygdala behavior (if any).
Scientists have only just started looking at the physiological changes that are brought about in the brain due to social and cultural conditionings. More interesting studies are definitely in the pipeline :).

(Hide) (Show)

13 Comments:

At May 09, 2005 1:29 AM, Blogger wise donkey said...
agree, a wider research required.

and why just black and white can also try with features like those of asians etc too..

but cant understand why an afroamerican would have increased activity when presented with another afroamerican face. will it apply even if the face is familiar or that of their friends too?
 
At May 09, 2005 1:40 AM, Blogger Sray said...
With friends, it didnt apply.. since people have good emotions attached to friends' faces. But if you have seen a face before, and know nothing about it, it seems both black and white Americans' amygdala reacted simiarly to it.

I agree that studies need to be done with Asian, Indian, SouthAmerican faces, etc. But this is only a preliminary study, I am sure it will be expanded in the future!
 
At May 09, 2005 3:33 AM, Blogger Onkroes said...
This is scary stuff for all sorts of reasons!

It's worrying if racial stereotyping is really so culturally pervasive, because 'curing' that is going to be one hell of a hard job.

However your phrase "conditions our brain to distrust anything that is out of the ordinary" caught my eye, because I found myself thinking about genetic disorders and wondering if anyone had considered ways of trying to change the function of the amygdala by genetic manipulation. I'm worried that I may just be showing my ignorance of what is possible in the art/science of genetics, but if it could be done then you can bet someone's thought of it.

It seems to me that this is a valid self-protection mechanism that is being measured, and while it seems to be demonstrating cultural racism, it should be addressed by behavioural modification rather than genetic 'tampering'.

I look forward to wider research, and hope that happens before the rather more sensationalist side of the press get hold of it.
 
At May 09, 2005 7:07 AM, Blogger Sray said...
Well, amygdala serves a lot of useful function too! It allows to be afraid of things.. and not take too much risk. So it makes us cautious, and a little caution is always healthy.

Amygdala is part of the limbic brain, and is present in mammals as well as reptiles. But our frontal cortex allows us to think, and override signals from the amygdala. So, unless we are slaves of our reptilian brain, it really shouldnt create problems.

But when we are acting on impulse, or are too tired, the amygdala takes over, and this is very dangerous, for example, a tired soldier can just kill off everyone without thinking about the consequences.
 
At May 09, 2005 10:22 AM, Blogger LEMNA said...
:((
I have bitttttten!I donn wanna ittt!!!
:D
 
At May 09, 2005 10:23 AM, Blogger LEMNA said...
Emm,'n happy new template!!!:DAm I right?!
 
At May 09, 2005 10:49 AM, Blogger Sray said...
New template?! Nooo :-). But I did make some changes to the old one :D:D:D.
 
At May 09, 2005 2:01 PM, Blogger Sray said...
Yaa... there are a lot of things that can be done. But still this limited work is interesting, because it shows that our social experiences have direct physiological observables :-). Brain is slowly becoming more knowable!!
 
At May 09, 2005 9:22 PM, Blogger Tupinambah said...
It is surprising discovery but remains unclear how the brain works. It's still a great mystery...
 
At May 09, 2005 9:49 PM, Blogger Sray said...
Very true. It is a last frontier of sorts!
 
At May 10, 2005 1:26 AM, Blogger LEMNA said...
:D You see I havenn made a mistake!I understand the changes!:D
 
At May 11, 2005 4:30 AM, Blogger Wayne Smallman said...
I've often said that racism is an entirely natural response.

And the amount of flack I've got for that in the past is unreal.

Most people seem to assume that racism is largely social conditioning.

While this is true to some degree, this simply doesn't explain racism and other discriminatory behaviour an the larger, global scale.

For any one reaction to be so pervasive amongst types of people, then for me, logic has always suggested that we all harbour the same mechanism.

Now, while people argue that we no longer need this mechanism anymore, I think that what we see in the world around us points to this little region of our brain being exercised now more than ever.

With increasingly limited resources in impoverished nations, western values do not add up to much.

Mother nature does not add useless emotions. We have no emotional baggage.

Every emotion has survival value...
 
At May 11, 2005 5:31 PM, Blogger Sray said...
Definitely there are evolutionary reasons for racism. Humans evolved in small tribes, where tribal loyalties were paramount. But we do have to grow out of our programming, and not kill, hate, or hurt each other. But, also we cannot hide the obvious truth that each of us has some prejudice built in, which are only reinforced by social and cultural taboos and norms and practices.

But it might be that this emotion has outlasted its survival value. We have developed technologically much faster than we have grown evolutionarily, and so much interconnection between communities is causing friction. We need to acknowledge that, and then work to minimize this friction. There is no other easy way.
 

Post a Comment